Strategic Reasons Brokerages Are Bypassing Zillow
How the NAR Settlement Is Transforming the Real Estate Industry: Strategic Reasons Brokerages Are Withholding Listings from Zillow
The real estate sector is experiencing a profound transformation following the National Association of Realtors (NAR) settlement in March 2024, which has redefined the structure of agent commissions. This pivotal agreement, resulting from antitrust litigation such as Burnett et al. v. National Association of Realtors, eliminates the longstanding practice of sellers automatically covering buyer’s agent commissions—a practice often criticized for inflating transaction costs. In response, many brokerages are strategically opting to withhold new listings from major online platforms like Zillow. This decision aligns with the evolving commission framework, enhancing brokerage control, profitability, and client relationships. This article examines the rationale behind this trend, focusing on the NAR settlement’s implications, while adhering to best SEO practices.
The NAR Settlement: A Paradigm Shift in Real Estate Commissions
In March 2024, the NAR finalized a $418 million settlement to address antitrust claims that its policies compelled sellers to pay inflated commissions, typically 5-6% of a property’s sale price, shared between listing and buyer’s agents. Effective August 17, 2024, the settlement introduced two transformative changes:
Elimination of Buyer’s Agent Commission Listings on MLS: Sellers are no longer obligated to advertise or pay commissions for buyer’s agents on Multiple Listing Services (MLS), dismantling the tradition of sellers funding both sides of the commission.
Mandatory Buyer-Agent Agreements: Buyers must now enter written agreements with their agents before viewing properties, specifying services and compensation terms. This shifts the responsibility of buyer’s agent fees to the buyer, unless otherwise negotiated.
These changes disrupt the conventional “cooperative compensation” model, empowering sellers to reduce costs significantly—potentially saving $6,000 to $12,000 on a $417,000 home, per TD Cowen Insights. While fostering a more competitive market, the settlement introduces complexities that are prompting brokerages to reassess their listing strategies.
The NAR settlement has amplified the incentives for brokerages to retain listings on their proprietary platforms or smaller networks, leveraging the new commission structure to their advantage. Below are the key drivers of this strategy:
1. Maximizing Seller Cost Savings
By removing the obligation to pay buyer’s agent commissions, the NAR settlement enables sellers to save 2.5-3% of the sale price—approximately $10,000 on a $400,000 home. Brokerages are capitalizing on this by encouraging exclusive listings, emphasizing tailored marketing strategies that reduce reliance on Zillow broad reach. This approach allows brokerages to negotiate directly with buyers or their agents, ensuring sellers retain a larger share of the proceeds.
Brokerages can enhance client engagement by utilizing customer relationship management (CRM) software to highlight these savings and deliver personalized service in the post-NAR environment.
2. Securing Direct Buyer Leads
Zillow generate revenue by capturing leads from listings and reselling them to agents or brokerages at a premium. With the NAR settlement requiring buyers to negotiate agent fees upfront, brokerages are bypassing these platforms to capture leads directly. By hosting exclusive listings on their websites, brokerages can engage buyers early in the process, guiding them through the new commission landscape before they commit to other agents.
Digital marketing tools, such as email marketing platforms, enable brokerages to nurture these leads independently, optimizing their lead generation efforts.
3. Reducing Platform Costs and Competition
Zillow impose substantial fees for advertising, lead generation, and premium listing placements. In a market where commissions are under pressure due to the NAR settlement, these costs are increasingly difficult to justify. By focusing on proprietary channels, brokerages eliminate these expenses and reduce competition from agents on the same platforms. This is particularly significant as buyer’s agents must now demonstrate their value to clients, creating challenges for less experienced professionals.
Brokerages can bolster their online presence with real estate-optimized themes, developing professional websites that rival the user experience of major platforms at a lower cost.
4. Safeguarding Seller Interests in a Negotiated Market
While the NAR settlement prohibits blanket commission offers on MLS, Zillow public platforms may still display “seller concessions” or compensation details, potentially attracting unqualified buyers or lowball offers. By withholding listings from these platforms, brokerages can vet prospects more thoroughly, ensuring only serious buyers access properties. This aligns with sellers’ preferences for efficient, high-quality transactions.
Technologies such as virtual tour software allow brokerages to create exclusive, immersive property showcases for pre-qualified buyers, enhancing seller privacy and confidence.
5. Driving Traffic to Brokerage Platforms
With buyer’s agent commissions no longer guaranteed, brokerages are incentivizing buyers to visit their websites for exclusive listings unavailable on Zillow. This increased traffic improves search engine rankings and creates opportunities to cross-sell services such as mortgage or title insurance. The NAR settlement’s focus on transparency further encourages buyers to engage directly with brokerages to explore commission structures.
SEO tools can optimize brokerage websites, ensuring higher visibility on search engines and reducing dependence on third-party platforms.
Broader Implications of the NAR Settlement
Industry analysts project that the NAR settlement could reduce commissions by 25-50%, aligning U.S. fees with the 1-3% rates observed in markets like the UK and Singapore. While this benefits sellers, it challenges buyer’s agents, who must now negotiate fees directly with clients. Brokerages withholding listings from Zillow are well-positioned to navigate this shift by:
Attracting Committed Buyers: Exclusive listings appeal to buyers willing to negotiate commissions or cover their agent’s fees, yielding higher-quality leads.
Strengthening Negotiation Leverage: Limited listing exposure creates urgency, potentially driving competitive offers and maximizing seller returns.
Customizing Marketing Efforts: Brokerages can utilize tools like drone photography equipment to present properties distinctively, differentiating their listings from standard Zillow posts.
Strategies for Brokerages to Succeed Post-NAR Settlement
To thrive in this transformed landscape, brokerages should adopt the following approaches:
Develop Robust Websites: Leverage website hosting services to create intuitive platforms showcasing exclusive listings.
Harness Social Media: Promote listings on platforms like Instagram and Facebook with targeted campaigns to attract buyers navigating the new commission rules.
Educate Clients: Utilize CRM tools to communicate the NAR settlement’s benefits, such as commission savings, to both sellers and buyers.
Monitor Performance: Employ analytics tools like Google Analytics to track website traffic and refine marketing strategies.
Google Ads is one of the most powerful tools for real estate agents looking to generate leads. With billions of searches every day, Google puts your business in front of people actively looking for properties or real estate services.
The 2024 NAR settlement has fundamentally altered the real estate industry by eliminating the requirement for sellers to pay buyer’s agent commissions, delivering significant cost savings and fostering a more competitive market. By withholding listings from Zillow, brokerages are strategically prioritizing control, cost efficiency, and direct client relationships. Through investments in SEO software, virtual tour technology, and digital marketing platforms, brokerages can adapt to this new era while delivering exceptional value to clients.
Discover Oral Health Benefits Like Never Before!
Transform your oral health with ProvaDent. Developed by Dr. Knudson, a board-certified dentist with over 30 years of experience, ProvaDent is a revolutionary dental supplement backed by science to support a balanced oral microbiome, promote fresh breath, and remineralize teeth overnight. Trusted by thousands, this formula offers a risk-free path to a healthier smile with a 60-day, 100% money-back guarantee. Take the first step toward sparkling oral health today—no dental myths, just real results.